Manatal has a clear pitch for recruiters: an ATS and a recruitment CRM in one, AI recommendations that match candidates to jobs, and published prices from $15 per user per month billed annually. It's tailored for HR teams, recruitment agencies and headhunters, and for many of them it's a sensible, affordable base.
Recruiters still compare alternatives as their desks change. A growing agency may need deeper client and business development tools, or may outgrow the 15 jobs on Manatal's Professional plan and want to compare its higher tiers with other tools. A contract desk may need timesheets and billing. Others want a different first-round screen, or fewer separate subscriptions for e-signature, call notes and invoicing.
One thing to accept before you start: most tools on this list cost more per seat than Manatal. The case for any of them is what the extra spend replaces or adds, not a lower bill.
What we compared, and why
- Client CRM depth. Leads, deals, client portals and business development, the work that wins the roles you fill.
- First-round screening. How applicants are assessed, and whether a person or the software decides who moves on.
- Outreach. Which channels sequences cover, and what's still in Beta or coming soon.
- Consolidation. Whether notes, e-signature, invoicing or timesheets live in the same tool or in four others.
- What's metered. Credits, add-ons and plan caps that change the real per-seat cost.
The products appear in our plan's order, which is not a ranking.
Daialog
DaialogSee how it worksA recruiting platform for independent recruiters and agencies that combines an ATS, CRM, InstantIntro AI screening, an AI notetaker, e-signature and invoicing.
- Pricing
- Recruiter $119 per seat per month ($99 billed annually); Recruiter Plus $299 per seat per month ($259 billed annually); Recruiter Custom for 11+ seats by quote. Pricing page
- Best for
- Solo recruiters, boutique firms and agencies that want screening, client work and admin in one workspace instead of several tools.
- Key features
- ATS and CRM: Candidate Hub, Intro Hub, roles, departments and clients
- Unlimited job postings and InstantIntros on every Recruiter and Team plan
- InstantIntro: each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, assessed against the role
- AI Notetaker for Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls, with summaries and interview scorecards
- Collaboration Hub: share shortlists with hiring managers and clients and collect feedback (Recruiter Plus)
What Daialog brings to a recruiter's desk
Daialog puts the work around a placement in one workspace. The core is an ATS and CRM, with Candidate Hub, Intro Hub, roles, departments and clients. On Recruiter Plus, the same workspace holds the Collaboration Hub for sharing shortlists with clients and collecting feedback, Signature Hub for client agreements and offer letters, native invoicing, and Business Development for finding client companies and contacts.
InstantIntro is where the screening differs. Each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, Daialog's AI screening agent, which assesses it against the role and gives one Match Score with an explanation. Candidates know they're talking with an AI. Daia doesn't decide who moves forward; you do, and there's no automatic rejection or knockout. The AI Notetaker, included in every plan, writes English transcripts, summaries and interview scorecards for Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls, with Zoom coming soon.
A solo recruiter can start on the Recruiter plan; see how that works for solo recruiters. A firm that sells as much as it fills will want Recruiter Plus, covered on the boutique firms page.
Limits to weigh
- Business Development, invoicing, Signature Hub and Collaboration Hub require Recruiter Plus, at $299 per seat per month ($259 billed annually). Those are the consolidation features, so price Recruiter Plus, not only the entry plan.
- Talent Search and messaging sequences for email and LinkedIn are in Beta. Text-message steps are coming soon, and Daialog sends no texts today.
- There's no contract-staffing back office: no timesheets, payroll or VMS connections.
Daialog brings the ATS, CRM, InstantIntro screening, the AI Notetaker, e-signature and invoicing together for recruiters and agencies. Start a free trial
Recruit CRM
Recruit CRMOfficial siteRecruit CRM describes itself as an AI-first ATS and CRM that helps recruitment agencies place more candidates, faster.
- Pricing
- Per user/month in USD: Pro $95, Business $135, Enterprise $215 billed annually, or $109, $159, $259 billed monthly. Each plan includes monthly credits for usage-based features. Pricing page
- Timesheets are priced per active contractor per month in credits: 100 credits (about $10) for 1–15 contractors, 90 credits (about $9) at higher volumes; timesheets export as XLSX or CSV or through the API.
- Best for
- Recruitment agencies, including contract staffing firms, wanting ATS, CRM, outreach and billing in one tool; the vendor says in-house teams can use it too.
- Key features
- Combined ATS and CRM with one record for candidates, clients, jobs, deals and business development.
- Multi-step outreach sequences across email, LinkedIn and SMS that stop when a contact replies on any channel.
- Hiring manager portal where clients review candidates and leave feedback that syncs back in real time.
- Timesheets, pay-and-bill rules and branded invoicing for contract staffing, with contractor and client portals.
- Job board posting, Chrome sourcing extension, Kanban pipelines, mobile app and executive search reports (Business and up).
For agencies that live in their CRM
Recruit CRM keeps candidates, clients, jobs, deals and business development on one record, which is the main draw for a recruiter whose client tracking has outgrown a simple pipeline. Its outreach runs as multi-step sequences across email, LinkedIn and SMS that stop when a contact replies on any channel, and a hiring manager portal lets clients review candidates and leave feedback that syncs back in real time.
For contract desks, it adds timesheets, pay-and-bill rules and branded invoicing, with contractor and client portals. ARC agents handle resume formatting, candidate submissions and pitch emails, and Recruit CRM MCP connects assistants such as Claude and ChatGPT to your account data.
Where the cost adds up
- Usage-based features, including AI sourcing, data enrichment, the notetaker, LinkedIn messaging, analytics and workflow automation, draw on a monthly credit pool. Heavy users should ask what extra credits cost.
- The Pro plan is limited to 1 hiring pipeline, 15 custom fields and 1 outreach sequence, without open API access or SSO, so an agency moving for CRM depth will likely price Business or Enterprise.
- Its Meeting Notetaker has Zoom support coming soon, per the vendor.
- It isn't a payroll processor: pay data is exported for payroll, and QuickBooks and Xero sync is listed as coming soon.
Zoho Recruit
Cloud-based, AI-powered recruiting platform and applicant tracking system for HR teams and staffing agencies, with separate corporate and staffing editions.
- Pricing
- Corporate: Free; Standard US$25, Enterprise US$50 per recruiter/month billed annually ($30/$60 monthly). Staffing: Standard $25, Professional $50, Enterprise $75 per user/month annually ($30/$60/$90 monthly). Taxes extra. Pricing page
- Best for
- HR teams and staffing agencies wanting published per-user pricing, a free entry plan (corporate edition) and integration with other Zoho apps.
- Key features
- Separate pricing editions for corporate HR teams and for staffing agencies.
- Candidate sourcing, resume management, premium job boards, branded careers site, employee referrals and assessments.
- Blueprint process enforcement, recruitment automation, auto responders and layout rules on the Enterprise plan.
- Candidate and staffing portals, plus SMS and Phonebridge, on the Enterprise plan.
- Add-ons for employee referral licenses, a vendor portal and one-way or live video interviews.
For price-conscious desks and firms already on Zoho
Of these five, Zoho Recruit sits closest to Manatal on price. It has separate editions for corporate HR teams and for staffing agencies, and the staffing edition starts at $25 per user per month billed annually. If your firm already runs Zoho CRM, Zoho People or Zoho Sign, it connects to them, which can matter more than any single feature.
On the AI side, Zia Matches pairs candidates with jobs and jobs with candidates, Zia Summaries condense profiles, assessments, notes and emails, and a careers-site chatbot answers applicant questions, collects details and runs pre-screening assessments. Blueprint process enforcement, candidate and staffing portals, and SMS and Phonebridge are on the Enterprise plan.
What to confirm first
- Zoho's pricing is clearest for the corporate edition: there, AI Candidate Matching is listed for Enterprise rather than Standard, and active jobs are capped per recruiter license, 10 on Standard and 20 on Enterprise. Ask how the staffing edition handles both.
- The free plan belongs to the corporate edition, allows one active job per recruiter license and doesn't support add-ons.
- Video interviews are a paid add-on at US$12 per job opening.
Recruiterflow
RecruiterflowOfficial siteRecruiterflow describes itself as AI-native recruiting software, an ATS and CRM built for executive search, recruiting and staffing firms.
- Pricing
- Platform Plan: USD $119 per user/month billed annually, or $149 billed monthly. AIRA Plan (adds AIRA agents and notetaker): custom pricing. EUR and GBP are also selectable. Pricing page
- Best for
- Search, recruiting and staffing firms wanting ATS, sales CRM and multichannel sequences in one place, with optional AI agents on a higher plan.
- Key features
- ATS with custom pipelines per job, resume parsing in 30+ languages and posting to major job boards (vendor figure)
- Multichannel sequences across email, calls, SMS and professional networks, with branching logic and step-level tracking.
- Sales CRM with custom deal pipelines, closing probabilities per stage and sales automation.
- Client portal where clients add notes and feedback, with recruiter control over what they can see.
- Chrome extension for bulk sourcing, branded careers page, unlimited records, reports and API access on the Platform plan.
For search firms that sell and recruit in one system
Recruiterflow is built for executive search, recruiting and staffing firms, and its CRM leans toward selling: custom deal pipelines with closing probabilities per stage, sales automation, and a client portal where clients add notes and feedback while you control what they can see. Its multichannel sequences cover email, calls, SMS and professional networks, with branching logic.
The Platform plan includes a Chrome extension for bulk sourcing, a branded careers page, unlimited records, reports and API access. The AIRA plan adds AI agents for matchmaking, submissions, tasks, field updates and job-change alerts, plus the AIRA Notetaker, which creates transcripts and summaries that update records.
What to plan around
- The AIRA Notetaker, AI agents, the phone and email finder and job-change alerts need the AIRA plan, which is custom-priced; only the Platform plan has a list price.
- Self-serve CSV import is free, but white-glove migration is paid, priced by data volume and typically takes 6–8 weeks. Time the switch around a quiet stretch.
- It's built for search and recruiting firms and isn't marketed to in-house teams, which matters only if you also run in-house hiring projects.
CATS
Applicant tracking system and recruiting CRM for professional recruiters, built around configurable workflows, career portals and candidate communication tools.
SMS texting is listed for the US and Canada only. The Daxtra search integration requires a separate Daxtra account.
- Pricing
- Pricing page: one plan at $89/user/month ($110 shown struck through). Product page: $95/user paid annually, $115 monthly. Data migration $500. Signup page: no contracts, billed monthly. Pricing page
- Best for
- Professional recruiters and recruiting or staffing firms wanting a configurable ATS with client CRM at a published per-user price.
- Key features
- Custom and multiple workflows for different teams, job types or processes, with workflow automation triggers.
- CRM for client relationships, mass emailing and email marketing integrations.
- Multiple candidate-facing career portals and automatic job publishing.
- SMS texting, meeting scheduler and two-way calendar and email sync.
- Sourcing browser extension to add candidates and contacts from professional sites and social networks.
For recruiters who want to shape their own process
CATS is an ATS and recruiting CRM for professional recruiters, built around configurable workflows: several workflows for different teams, job types or processes, with workflow automation triggers. Around that sit a client CRM with mass emailing, multiple career portals, a sourcing browser extension, screening and knockout questions, structured scorecards, SMS texting, a meeting scheduler, and API access and webhooks.
A single plan priced per user keeps budgeting simple for a small firm, and its documented integrations include Mailchimp, Constant Contact, BambooHR, Checkr and Zapier.
Things to check
- Its pages show two list prices: $89 per user per month on the pricing page, and $95 per user paid annually or $115 monthly on the product page. Confirm the current price before you sign.
- Data migration is priced separately at $500, and the free trial is 7 days, so plan your test in advance.
- SMS texting is listed for the US and Canada only.
- CATS MCP gives AI assistants such as ChatGPT or Claude read-only access to find and summarize recruiting data; it's in closed alpha and enabled on request through support.
Match the tool to how your desk runs
- You recruit alone and most of your week is screening and calls. Daialog's Recruiter plan gives you InstantIntro and the notetaker without paying for BD tools. Zoho Recruit keeps the per-seat cost lower, and CATS offers one configurable plan.
- You run a boutique firm that wins clients as well as filling roles. Compare Daialog's Recruiter Plus, Recruiterflow's sales CRM and Recruit CRM's combined record. The deciding factor is usually which one your team will actually keep updated.
- You place contractors. Recruit CRM lists timesheets, pay-and-bill rules and contractor portals, and Recruiterflow's integration directory includes timesheet tools. Daialog isn't a fit for that back office.
- Your firm already runs on Zoho. Zoho Recruit's links to Zoho CRM, People and Sign may outweigh feature differences.
- You like Manatal and price is the main constraint. Staying is a reasonable outcome. Its Enterprise plan adds workflow automations, Enterprise Plus adds SSO and open API access, and the AI Interviewer add-on runs video screening interviews in six languages.
Our guides to ATS options for small recruiting agencies and recruiting software for solo recruiters go further on those two setups, and our guide to Bullhorn alternatives compares a different set of agency tools.
Questions to put to each vendor on a demo
- Which features you've just seen are add-ons, credit-based or Beta on the plan I'd actually buy?
- How do my Manatal clients, contacts, notes and placements come across, who does the import, and what does it cost?
- When the AI scores or ranks a candidate, can I see why, and who makes the call to move them forward?
- Which meeting platforms does the notetaker support today, and which are only planned?
- Which outreach channels work now, and which are listed as coming soon?
- What happens to my data and my clients' portal access if I leave?










