Ask five ATS vendors whether they offer AI screening and you can get five yeses that mean five different things. One scores each applicant against your job criteria, another matches and summarizes, another surfaces likely fits without rating anyone, and some will interview the candidate for you. Each produces different evidence, and each is paid for differently: inside the plan, through usage credits, or as an add-on or a higher tier.
The difference matters because applications themselves are changing. In a 2024 survey of hiring managers in the UK and Ireland, 74% said they can tell when AI wrote an application (CV Genius survey). AI that reviews the application works with what the applicant chose to submit, while an AI interview collects answers in the moment. Interviews ask more of candidates; application review asks nothing extra of them.
This guide sets out what each platform's AI is documented to do and which plan carries it, then looks at whether screening belongs inside the ATS at all.
How we compared the AI in each ATS
- What the AI does: scores against criteria, matches and summarizes, reviews profiles, or interviews the candidate.
- How it shows its work: reasoning, a summary, a transcript or an explanation a recruiter can check.
- Where it sits in the price: in the plan, metered by credits, an add-on, or a higher tier.
- Who decides: whether a person still chooses who advances.
- The team it's built for: employers hiring for themselves, agencies and search firms, or both.
Each platform fits a different team, and the order below isn't a ranking.
Daialog
DaialogSee how it worksA recruiting platform for independent recruiters and agencies that combines an ATS, CRM, InstantIntro AI screening, an AI notetaker, e-signature and invoicing.
- Pricing
- Recruiter $119 per seat per month ($99 billed annually); Recruiter Plus $299 per seat per month ($259 billed annually); Recruiter Custom for 11+ seats by quote. Pricing page
- Best for
- Solo recruiters, boutique firms and agencies that want screening, client work and admin in one workspace instead of several tools.
- Key features
- ATS and CRM: Candidate Hub, Intro Hub, roles, departments and clients
- Unlimited job postings and InstantIntros on every Recruiter and Team plan
- InstantIntro: each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, assessed against the role
- AI Notetaker for Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls, with summaries and interview scorecards
- Collaboration Hub: share shortlists with hiring managers and clients and collect feedback (Recruiter Plus)
Screening built in as a conversation
Daialog is a recruiting platform for independent recruiters and agencies that combines an ATS and CRM with InstantIntro AI screening, an AI notetaker, e-signature and invoicing. Screening here is a conversation built into the platform rather than an add-on: each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, Daialog's AI screening agent, which assesses it against the role and gives one Match Score with an explanation. Candidates know they're talking with an AI. Daia doesn't decide who moves forward; your recruiters do, and there's no automatic rejection or knockout.
The AI also works around the screen. Daia drafts roles with you, including the description and the InstantIntro questions. The AI Notetaker, included in every plan, joins Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls and writes summaries and interview scorecards.
On Recruiter Plus, the Collaboration Hub shares shortlists with clients and collects their feedback, and Talent Search (Beta) adds AI candidate sourcing. In-house teams would look at Daialog's Team plan, which is priced by company size rather than per seat. For a side-by-side view, see Daialog vs the competition.
Gaps to plan for
- Business Development, invoicing, Signature Hub and Collaboration Hub require Recruiter Plus.
- Talent Search and messaging sequences for email and LinkedIn are in Beta; text-message steps are coming soon, and Daialog sends no texts today.
- The AI Notetaker covers Google Meet and Microsoft Teams; Zoom support is coming soon.
- There's no contract-staffing back office: no timesheets, payroll or VMS.
Daialog brings the ATS, CRM, InstantIntro screening, the AI Notetaker, e-signature and invoicing together for recruiters and agencies. Start a free trial
Workable
WorkableOfficial siteTalent management platform pairing an applicant tracking system and HR modules with Workable Agent, an AI recruiting agent that sources, screens and engages candidates.
- Pricing
- Standard, Premier and Enterprise, priced in $ by company size. Recruiting for 1–20 employees: Standard $299/month annually ($360 monthly), Premier $599, Enterprise $719 (annual only). Agent AI credits extra. Pricing page
- Best for
- Employers, from small businesses to larger companies, wanting recruiting and optional HR in one system, with usage-based AI agents.
- Key features
- Posts jobs to 200+ job boards at once and includes a no-code careers page builder (vendor figure)
- Sourcing across a database of 400M+ candidate profiles, plus a Chrome extension for LinkedIn profiles (vendor figure)
- Talent CRM, interview kits and scorecards, self-scheduled interviews and two-way Gmail/365 calendar sync.
- Offer letter templates with approval flows, e-signatures and integrated background checks.
- Pre-built and custom reports, dashboards, scheduled report emails and data exports.
Criteria scores with the reasoning shown
Workable pairs an applicant tracking system and optional HR modules with Workable Agent, an AI recruiting agent that sources, screens and engages candidates. Its screening scores applicants against up to 14 job criteria and shows the reasoning behind every score, so a recruiter can check why someone scored as they did instead of trusting a bare number. The Job Brief Agent, included on all plans, helps define the role and the ideal candidate profile.
It suits employers, from small businesses to larger companies, that want recruiting and optional HR in one system. The AI sits where jobs, interview kits, scorecards and offers already live, and an MCP server and REST API let a company's own AI agents operate Workable within user permissions.
What the agent costs to run
- The Sourcing, Screening and Engagement agents consume paid AI credits, so budget for usage as well as the plan.
- The free trial excludes Workable Agent, so ask for a demo to see screening at work.
- Plan prices follow employee count, with no list price for 1,000+ employees; Premier and Enterprise are billed annually only.
- Texting, video interviews and assessments are paid add-ons on Standard.
Manatal
ManatalOfficial siteAI recruitment software for sourcing and hiring faster, combining an ATS and recruitment CRM, tailored for HR teams, recruitment agencies and headhunters.
- Pricing
- Professional $15, Enterprise $35, Enterprise Plus $55 per user per month billed annually (USD); $19, $39, $59 on monthly plans. Custom plan on request. Pricing page
- Free job board posting needs account verification after the first payment; the trial excludes job board posting and mass emailing.
- Best for
- Recruitment and staffing agencies, freelance recruiters and in-house teams wanting low per-user pricing with client CRM and AI matching.
- Key features
- ATS with unlimited custom pipelines, boolean and AI semantic search, scorecards and knockout questions.
- Recruitment CRM for leads, clients, sales pipeline, placements and revenue tracking.
- Career page builder with custom domain, multiple languages and custom application forms.
- LinkedIn Chrome extension and sourcing from 10+ platforms; posts jobs to free and premium channels (vendor figure)
- Candidate portal and internal mobility features on the Enterprise Plus plan.
Matching, Copilot and an interviewer add-on
Manatal combines an ATS and recruitment CRM for HR teams, recruitment agencies and headhunters, and its AI is spread across several jobs rather than one screening step. AI recommendations match candidates to jobs with summaries, adjustable weighting and automatic scoring. AI Copilot, a chat assistant, produces candidate summaries, fit-and-gap analysis, interview prep and ranking, and AI enrichment adds data from social profiles such as LinkedIn and GitHub. The ATS also offers scorecards and knockout questions.
When you want the candidate interviewed, the AI Interviewer add-on runs 24/7 video screening interviews in six languages and evaluates the answers. Combined with per-user pricing and a client CRM, that suits agencies, freelance recruiters and in-house teams that want AI matching at a low per-user price.
Tier details to confirm
- The AI Interviewer is a paid add-on, and its price isn't listed on the pricing page.
- Professional is capped at 15 jobs and 10,000 candidates, and workflow automations need Enterprise or higher.
- SSO, open API access, user groups and LLM integration are Enterprise Plus features.
- The 14-day trial excludes job board posting and mass emailing. Confirm which tier includes AI recommendations and Copilot before you price seats.
Ashby
AshbyOfficial siteAn all-in-one recruiting platform combining ATS, CRM and sourcing, scheduling and analytics, with AI embedded across the product.
- Pricing
- Foundations (up to 100 employees): $300–$900 per month by company size, monthly or yearly terms, 10% off annual commitments. Plus, Enterprise and Analytics: priced on request. Pricing page
- Best for
- Companies from startups to enterprises wanting ATS, sourcing, scheduling and analytics in one system; Foundations pricing is published for teams up to 100 employees.
- Key features
- Automated multi-step email and LinkedIn sequences, a sourcing Chrome extension and Boolean candidate search.
- Posts jobs to a hosted job board and third-party boards including LinkedIn, Indeed and Google Jobs.
- Interview plans with direct booking from panel calendars and candidate availability links.
- Offer letters from templates with built-in e-signatures and multi-step approval workflows.
- Prebuilt and custom dashboards, a report builder and scheduled dashboard delivery by email or Slack.
Review that surfaces fits without a number
Ashby is an all-in-one recruiting platform that combines ATS, CRM and sourcing, scheduling and analytics, with AI embedded across the product. Its screening takes a distinct position: AI-assisted application review surfaces applicants who match the criteria you set, and Ashby says its AI never ranks or numerically rates applicants. For teams that would rather not have a number standing between a recruiter and an application, that's the design they're buying.
Elsewhere, Ashby Assistant and custom agents analyze pipelines, update candidates and draft communications. When you want more than review, two AI products are sold as add-ons: an AI Interviewer that conducts structured, job-specific interviews with transcript-based evaluations, and an AI Notetaker that records, transcribes and summarizes interviews and debriefs. Ashby is aimed at companies from startups to enterprises.
Add-ons and unpublished tiers
Foundations, for companies up to 100 employees, has published prices by company size; Plus, Enterprise and standalone Analytics are priced on request, based on company size, usage and commitment. The AI Interviewer and AI Notetaker are paid add-ons on every plan, as is advanced scheduling automation, and Foundations limits candidate experience surveys and offer templates to one each.
Recruiterflow
RecruiterflowOfficial siteRecruiterflow describes itself as AI-native recruiting software, an ATS and CRM built for executive search, recruiting and staffing firms.
- Pricing
- Platform Plan: USD $119 per user/month billed annually, or $149 billed monthly. AIRA Plan (adds AIRA agents and notetaker): custom pricing. EUR and GBP are also selectable. Pricing page
- Best for
- Search, recruiting and staffing firms wanting ATS, sales CRM and multichannel sequences in one place, with optional AI agents on a higher plan.
- Key features
- ATS with custom pipelines per job, resume parsing in 30+ languages and posting to major job boards (vendor figure)
- Multichannel sequences across email, calls, SMS and professional networks, with branching logic and step-level tracking.
- Sales CRM with custom deal pipelines, closing probabilities per stage and sales automation.
- Client portal where clients add notes and feedback, with recruiter control over what they can see.
- Chrome extension for bulk sourcing, branded careers page, unlimited records, reports and API access on the Platform plan.
AI that works the search-firm desk
Recruiterflow describes itself as AI-native recruiting software: an ATS and CRM built for executive search, recruiting and staffing firms. The AI it documents works the recruiter's side of a search. AIRA agents handle matchmaking, submissions, tasks, field updates and job-change alerts; AIRA Search runs natural-language searches; Ask AIRA reviews many profiles without opening each one; and AIRA Source searches a vendor-stated 850M+ profiles and enriches the ones you add with email and phone.
For a search firm, that AI sits next to a sales CRM with deal pipelines and closing probabilities, a client portal for client notes and feedback, and multichannel sequences with branching logic. Zoom, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls can be transcribed and summarized by the AIRA Notetaker, which updates records.
Where the AIRA plan comes in
- AIRA agents, the AIRA Notetaker, the phone and email finder and job-change alerts require the AIRA plan, which is custom-priced.
- It's built for search and recruiting firms, and the vendor doesn't market it to in-house teams.
- Self-serve CSV import is free; white-glove migration is paid, priced by data volume, and typically takes 6–8 weeks.
Built into the ATS, or added next to it?
Native AI screening has a plain advantage: the score, summary or interview lands on the candidate record your team already uses, with nothing to sync and one vendor to call. All five platforms here put AI inside their own ATS, though Manatal's and Ashby's AI interviewers are bought as add-ons.
The case for a separate screening tool is just as practical. Moving jobs, candidates and email history to a new ATS is a project of its own, and if your ATS works, switching only to change the first-round screen is a large trade. Daialog sells its screening both ways: built into its platform, or as a standalone InstantIntro plan that works alongside an existing ATS. That plan connects directly to Workable, and to other ATSs, including Ashby, through a third-party connector.
Our guide to AI screening for your existing ATS covers that route in detail. Agencies weighing a full switch can compare all-in-one recruiting software for agencies.
Which plan carries the AI
Before a demo, map each platform's AI to the line on the price list that pays for it:
- Workable: the Job Brief Agent is on all plans; the Sourcing, Screening and Engagement agents run on paid AI credits.
- Manatal: the AI Interviewer is a paid add-on with no listed price, and LLM integration is on Enterprise Plus; ask which tier includes AI recommendations and Copilot.
- Daialog: InstantIntro isn't among the Recruiter Plus extras, and the AI Notetaker is in every plan; Talent Search (Beta) is on Recruiter Plus and Team.
- Ashby: the AI Interviewer and AI Notetaker are paid add-ons on every plan; Plus and Enterprise are priced on request.
- Recruiterflow: AIRA agents and the AIRA Notetaker need the custom-priced AIRA plan; the Platform Plan includes the Chrome extension for bulk sourcing, a branded careers page, unlimited records, reports and API access.
Then put the same three questions to every vendor: what evidence does a recruiter see behind each AI result, can a recruiter override it, and what happens to the candidates the AI doesn't surface?








