Comparison guideby

5 Applicant Tracking Systems for Small Recruiting Agencies

Five ATS options for agencies with fewer than 10 recruiters, compared on seat cost, job board posting, client records and the move off spreadsheets.

Daialog wrote this guide, and Daialog is one of the products in it. Every other product's features and prices were checked against its own website; the links are under Sources.

The short answer

Daialog fits agencies that want screening and client work in one workspace. Zoho Recruit fits cost-conscious agencies that want a staffing edition with published per-user prices and Zoho app integrations. CATS fits recruiters who want one configurable plan with client CRM and a priced migration service. PCRecruiter fits perm and executive search desks of roughly 1 to 25 recruiters. Manatal fits agencies after low per-user prices with client CRM and AI matching.

Who this guide is for

Owners and lead recruiters at agencies with fewer than about 10 recruiters, buying a first proper ATS to replace spreadsheets, with job posting and client records high on the list.

At a glance
ProductWhy it's on this listBest forPricing
DaialogAll-in-one recruiting platform with AI screeningATS and client CRM with InstantIntro screening and the AI Notetaker, for small agencies that want fewer separate tools.Solo recruiters, boutique firms and agencies that want screening, client work and admin in one workspace instead of several tools.From $99 per seat per month (billed annually)Free trial available
Zoho RecruitATS for HR teams and staffing agenciesA separate staffing edition from $25 per user per month billed annually, with job boards, a careers site and Zoho app integrations.HR teams and staffing agencies wanting published per-user pricing, a free entry plan (corporate edition) and integration with other Zoho apps.From US$25 per recruiter per month (billed annually)Free plan available
CATSATS and recruiting CRM for professional recruitersOne published per-user plan covering ATS, client CRM and job publishing, with data migration offered as a $500 service.Professional recruiters and recruiting or staffing firms wanting a configurable ATS with client CRM at a published per-user price.From $89 per user per month (pricing page)Free trial: 7 days
PCRecruiterRecruitment CRM and ATS for agenciesAimed at boutique perm and search firms of roughly 1 to 25 recruiters, with job orders, deals and job board distribution.Boutique and growing recruiting firms of roughly 1-25 recruiters placing permanent roles, plus retained and contingency executive search firms.From $125 per user per month
ManatalAI recruitment software: ATS and CRMFrom $15 per user per month billed annually, with a client and placement CRM and posting to free and premium job channels.Recruitment and staffing agencies, freelance recruiters and in-house teams wanting low per-user pricing with client CRM and AI matching.From $15 per user per month (Professional, billed annually)Free trial: 14 days

Prices are as each vendor publishes them, in US dollars unless noted, and can change. Taxes, add-ons and volume discounts aren't included.

When a small agency outgrows its spreadsheet, the symptoms are familiar. Two recruiters call the same candidate in the same week. A client asks who was on last month's shortlist and nobody can find the tab. Job ads get pasted into each board by hand.

The fix is an applicant tracking system the whole desk keeps up to date. For an agency under about 10 recruiters, the choice turns on a few practical questions: what the seats cost at the tier you'll really use, how the spreadsheet gets in, whether job posting is built in, and whether client companies and contacts sit next to candidates instead of in a separate tool.

At this stage, those basics matter more than AI features. All five systems below publish prices, and each section reads their features against a small agency's working day.

What we weighed for a small agency

  • Seat cost at three to ten users, at the plan tier that holds what you need, not only the entry price.
  • The move off spreadsheets: whether import is a paid service, a quoted setup fee, or something to confirm on a trial.
  • Job posting: a careers page and distribution to job boards from the same system.
  • Client records: companies, contacts and job orders alongside candidates, so a placement's history sits in one place.

The products appear in no particular order, and the order isn't a ranking.

Daialog

A recruiting platform for independent recruiters and agencies that combines an ATS, CRM, InstantIntro AI screening, an AI notetaker, e-signature and invoicing.

Pricing
Recruiter $119 per seat per month ($99 billed annually); Recruiter Plus $299 per seat per month ($259 billed annually); Recruiter Custom for 11+ seats by quote. Pricing page
Best for
Solo recruiters, boutique firms and agencies that want screening, client work and admin in one workspace instead of several tools.
Key features
  • ATS and CRM: Candidate Hub, Intro Hub, roles, departments and clients
  • Unlimited job postings and InstantIntros on every Recruiter and Team plan
  • InstantIntro: each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, assessed against the role
  • AI Notetaker for Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls, with summaries and interview scorecards
  • Collaboration Hub: share shortlists with hiring managers and clients and collect feedback (Recruiter Plus)

Why a small agency would shortlist it

Daialog's ATS and CRM keep candidates (in Candidate Hub and Intro Hub), roles, departments and clients together. What sets it apart from a plain ATS is what comes with the seat. InstantIntro gives each applicant a short spoken conversation with Daia, Daialog's AI screening agent, which assesses it against the role and returns one Match Score with an explanation. Candidates know they're talking with an AI, and Daia doesn't decide who moves forward: your recruiters do.

The AI Notetaker joins Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls and writes summaries and interview scorecards, and Daia drafts the role description and InstantIntro questions with you. The Recruiter plan is $119 per seat per month, or $99 billed annually. Recruiter Plus, at $299 per seat per month or $259 billed annually, adds Business Development, invoicing, Signature Hub and Collaboration Hub for sharing shortlists with clients. Agencies with 11 or more seats move to Recruiter Custom, priced by quote, and a free trial is available. See how this works for boutique firms and for solo recruiters.

Costs and catches

  • Client agreements, invoicing, client shortlist sharing and Business Development need Recruiter Plus, so price that tier if you want them.
  • The Notetaker covers Google Meet and Microsoft Teams, with English transcripts; Zoom support is coming soon.
  • Talent Search and messaging sequences are in Beta, and text-message steps are coming soon.
  • It's built for recruiting work, not contract back office: no timesheets, payroll or VMS.

Daialog brings the ATS, CRM, InstantIntro screening, the AI Notetaker, e-signature and invoicing together for recruiters and agencies. Start a free trial

Zoho Recruit

Zoho RecruitOfficial site

Cloud-based, AI-powered recruiting platform and applicant tracking system for HR teams and staffing agencies, with separate corporate and staffing editions.

Pricing
Corporate: Free; Standard US$25, Enterprise US$50 per recruiter/month billed annually ($30/$60 monthly). Staffing: Standard $25, Professional $50, Enterprise $75 per user/month annually ($30/$60/$90 monthly). Taxes extra. Pricing page
  • Corporate plans cap active jobs per recruiter license: 10 on Standard, 20 on Enterprise.
Best for
HR teams and staffing agencies wanting published per-user pricing, a free entry plan (corporate edition) and integration with other Zoho apps.
Key features
  • Separate pricing editions for corporate HR teams and for staffing agencies.
  • Candidate sourcing, resume management, premium job boards, branded careers site, employee referrals and assessments.
  • Blueprint process enforcement, recruitment automation, auto responders and layout rules on the Enterprise plan.
  • Candidate and staffing portals, plus SMS and Phonebridge, on the Enterprise plan.
  • Add-ons for employee referral licenses, a vendor portal and one-way or live video interviews.

Why a small agency would shortlist it

Zoho Recruit sells a staffing edition priced separately from its corporate edition for HR teams. The staffing tiers are Standard $25, Professional $50 and Enterprise $75 per user per month billed annually, or $30, $60 and $90 billed monthly, with taxes extra. That ladder lets a three-person desk start low and move up only when it needs to.

The feature list covers jobs a spreadsheet can't: resume management, premium job boards, a branded careers site, employee referrals and assessments. Zia Matches pairs candidates with jobs, AI Assist drafts job descriptions, emails and notes, and a careers-site chatbot answers applicant questions and runs pre-screening assessments. If your agency already uses other Zoho apps, Recruit integrates with Zoho CRM, People and Sign, as well as Indeed, CareerBuilder and LinkedIn.

Costs and catches

  • The free plan belongs to the corporate edition and allows one active job per recruiter license, with no add-ons. Agencies should price the staffing tiers.
  • Process enforcement (Blueprint), recruitment automation, candidate and staffing portals, and Phonebridge are listed on the Enterprise plan.
  • On corporate pricing, AI candidate matching sits on Enterprise rather than Standard, so ask which staffing tier includes it.
  • Video interviews are a paid add-on at US$12 per job opening.

CATS

Applicant tracking system and recruiting CRM for professional recruiters, built around configurable workflows, career portals and candidate communication tools.

SMS texting is listed for the US and Canada only.

Pricing
Pricing page: one plan at $89/user/month ($110 shown struck through). Product page: $95/user paid annually, $115 monthly. Data migration $500. Signup page: no contracts, billed monthly. Pricing page
  • Data migration is priced separately at $500.
Best for
Professional recruiters and recruiting or staffing firms wanting a configurable ATS with client CRM at a published per-user price.
Key features
  • Custom and multiple workflows for different teams, job types or processes, with workflow automation triggers.
  • CRM for client relationships, mass emailing and email marketing integrations.
  • Multiple candidate-facing career portals and automatic job publishing.
  • SMS texting, meeting scheduler and two-way calendar and email sync.
  • Sourcing browser extension to add candidates and contacts from professional sites and social networks.

Why a small agency would shortlist it

CATS is an ATS and recruiting CRM for professional recruiters, owned by Top Echelon since 2020 and sold as a single plan rather than a ladder of tiers. The product covers a client CRM, mass email, multiple career portals with automatic job publishing, and a browser extension for adding candidates and contacts from professional sites. Custom workflows let you run a different process per job type, and screening questions, scorecards and two-way email and calendar sync cover the daily work.

For a desk leaving spreadsheets, the useful detail is that CATS prices data migration at $500, so the import can be handed over at a known cost. Its signup page says there are no contracts and billing is monthly, which keeps the commitment small while you find out whether the team adopts it.

Costs and catches

  • The vendor's pages show different list prices: $89 per user per month on the pricing page, and $95 per user paid annually or $115 monthly on the product page. Get the rate in writing.
  • SMS texting is listed for the US and Canada only.
  • Its connection for AI assistants such as ChatGPT or Claude is read-only, in closed alpha and enabled on request through support.
  • The Daxtra search integration needs a separate Daxtra account.

PCRecruiter

PCRecruiterOfficial site

Recruitment CRM and ATS (PCRM) for growing agencies, keeping candidates, clients and business development in one place.

Pricing
From $125 per user per month; no minimum or seat cap; per-user rate moves with volume. One-time setup fee and data migration quoted before commitment. No free trial. Pricing page
  • The free API tier allows 5,000 calls per day; Premium costs $100/month for up to 50,000.
Best for
Boutique and growing recruiting firms of roughly 1-25 recruiters placing permanent roles, plus retained and contingency executive search firms.
Key features
  • Recruiting CRM with candidate, company and contact records, deals, job orders and configurable pipelines per role type.
  • Resume parsing, PCR Capture browser extension, careers-page job posting and distribution to job boards.
  • Multi-step candidate and business development sequences that stop when someone replies.
  • SMS, email integration with thread capture, templates and voice integration.
  • Activity, pipeline and placement reporting, with EEO and GDPR compliance tools and role-based permissions.

Why a small agency would shortlist it

PCRecruiter is aimed at boutique and growing firms of roughly 1 to 25 recruiters placing permanent roles, plus retained and contingency executive search. Its records follow agency work: companies, contacts, deals and job orders sit beside candidates, with pipelines configured per role type. On the posting side it has resume parsing, the PCR Capture browser extension, careers-page posting and distribution to job boards, with Indeed, LinkedIn, Dice and Broadbean among its integrations.

It also reaches past the ATS, with multi-step candidate and business development sequences that stop when someone replies, plus activity, pipeline and placement reporting. Its AI reads a job order and ranks the candidates you already hold, and MCP access for assistants such as Claude or ChatGPT is included in the price.

Costs and catches

  • Pricing starts at $125 per user per month, with no minimum or seat cap; the per-user rate moves with volume.
  • A one-time setup fee, based on configuration, and data migration are quoted before you commit.
  • There's no free trial. PCRecruiter offers a 20-minute call and a demo configured around your workflow instead.
  • AI matching ranks only records you already hold; sourcing from the open web needs a connected third-party tool.

Manatal

AI recruitment software for sourcing and hiring faster, combining an ATS and recruitment CRM, tailored for HR teams, recruitment agencies and headhunters.

Pricing
Professional $15, Enterprise $35, Enterprise Plus $55 per user per month billed annually (USD); $19, $39, $59 on monthly plans. Custom plan on request. Pricing page
Best for
Recruitment and staffing agencies, freelance recruiters and in-house teams wanting low per-user pricing with client CRM and AI matching.
Key features
  • ATS with unlimited custom pipelines, boolean and AI semantic search, scorecards and knockout questions.
  • Recruitment CRM for leads, clients, sales pipeline, placements and revenue tracking.
  • Career page builder with custom domain, multiple languages and custom application forms.
  • LinkedIn Chrome extension and sourcing from 10+ platforms; posts jobs to free and premium channels (vendor figure)
  • Candidate portal and internal mobility features on the Enterprise Plus plan.

Why a small agency would shortlist it

Manatal combines an ATS and a recruitment CRM at low per-user prices: Professional $15, Enterprise $35 and Enterprise Plus $55 per user per month billed annually, or $19, $39 and $59 on monthly plans. The CRM tracks leads, clients, sales pipeline, placements and revenue, so a small agency can follow a client from first contact to placement in the same system as its candidates.

For posting and sourcing, Manatal has a career page builder with a custom domain and custom application forms, posting to free and premium channels, and a LinkedIn Chrome extension. AI recommendations match candidates to jobs with adjustable weighting and automatic scoring, and AI enrichment adds data from social profiles such as LinkedIn and GitHub. If you're weighing it against similar tools, see Manatal alternatives.

Costs and catches

  • Professional is capped at 15 jobs and 10,000 candidates, and workflow automations need Enterprise or higher. An agency carrying more than 15 jobs should price Enterprise.
  • The 14-day trial excludes job board posting and mass emailing, and free job board posting needs account verification after the first payment, so posting can't be tested before you pay.
  • SSO, open API access, user groups and LLM integration are Enterprise Plus features.
  • The AI Interviewer is a paid add-on whose price isn't listed on the pricing page.

Five seats at list price

A five-recruiter agency is a useful yardstick. These monthly figures are each vendor's published per-user rate multiplied by five, before tax, add-ons, setup fees or volume pricing. They're arithmetic, not quotes.

  • Zoho Recruit, staffing Standard: $125 billed annually, $150 billed monthly.
  • CATS: $445 at the pricing page's $89 rate, or $475 billed annually and $575 monthly at the product page's rates. Data migration is $500 on top if you buy it.
  • PCRecruiter: from $625, plus a one-time setup fee quoted before you commit.
  • Daialog, Recruiter: $495 billed annually, $595 billed monthly. Recruiter Plus comes to $1,295 billed annually or $1,495 billed monthly.
  • Manatal, Professional: $75 billed annually, $95 billed monthly. Enterprise comes to $175 or $195.

The entry tier isn't always the one you'll run on. Price the tier that holds what you'd miss: automations on Manatal, portals and automation on Zoho Recruit's Enterprise plan, and e-signature and invoicing on Daialog's Recruiter Plus. A cheaper seat that forces you to keep a second tool can end up costing more.

Before you import the spreadsheet

In a first ATS, the import often decides whether the team adopts it. A short checklist:

  1. Split the sheet by record type. Candidates, client companies, client contacts and open jobs each need their own tab, so client history lands on the company record instead of in a notes column.
  2. Standardize stages and sources. Agree on a handful of pipeline stages and one spelling per job board before you map columns.
  3. Ask who does the import, and what it costs. CATS prices data migration at $500. PCRecruiter quotes setup and migration before you commit. With Zoho Recruit, Daialog and Manatal, ask during the trial whether import is self-serve or a paid service.
  4. Test on a real role. Zoho Recruit offers a 15-day trial, CATS 7 days and Manatal 14 days, without job board posting. Daialog has a free trial available, and PCRecruiter offers a configured demo instead.
  5. Post one live job. Check that it reaches the boards your candidates come from, and that applicants land in the right pipeline.
  6. Confirm you can export. Ask how you would get candidates, clients and notes out again if you ever switch.

If you're still deciding whether you need an ATS, a CRM or both, ATS vs recruiting CRM covers the difference. Working on your own? See recruiting software for solo recruiters.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a free ATS plan a small agency can use?

Zoho Recruit has a free plan, but it belongs to the corporate edition and allows one active job per recruiter license with no add-ons; the staffing edition starts at $25 per user per month billed annually. CATS, PCRecruiter, Daialog and Manatal don't offer a free plan. Zoho Recruit, CATS, Manatal and Daialog offer free trials, and PCRecruiter offers a demo configured around your workflow instead.

What does it cost to move our spreadsheet data into a new ATS?

CATS prices data migration at $500. PCRecruiter quotes a one-time setup fee and data migration before you commit. For Zoho Recruit, Daialog and Manatal, ask during the trial whether import is self-serve or a paid service, and clean the sheet first so clients, contacts and candidates come in as separate records.

Which of these systems post jobs to job boards?

Zoho Recruit lists premium job boards and integrates with Indeed, CareerBuilder and LinkedIn. CATS lists automatic job publishing and multiple career portals, PCRecruiter lists job board and distribution integrations including Indeed, LinkedIn, Dice and Broadbean, and Manatal posts to free and premium channels, with free board posting unlocked after account verification following the first payment. For Daialog, ask on a demo how roles reach the boards you use.

Does a small agency need a recruiting CRM as well as an ATS?

An agency works two sides, candidates and clients, so it needs both kinds of record. CATS, PCRecruiter, Daialog and Manatal keep client records in the same system as candidates. Zoho Recruit also integrates with Zoho CRM, if your client relationships already live there.

Does Daialog reject applicants automatically?

No. Each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, which assesses it against the role and gives one Match Score with an explanation. Daia doesn't decide who moves forward; your recruiters do, and there's no automatic rejection or knockout. Blind screening is optional and stays off until you turn it on.

Sources

Product features and prices were checked against these pages on November 17, 2026.

Written by the Daialog Editorial Team. How we research and check Insights.

More from Insights

Keep reading.

More in Agency & staffing software