How to Choose Recruiting Software for Your Agency: A Buyer's Checklist

A five-step checklist for agency owners: map one placement, sort must-haves, trial with a live role, read the exit terms and price the whole stack.

Daialog wrote this guide, and Daialog makes recruiting software. The research and pages it draws on are listed under Sources.

The short answer

Run five checks in order: map one recent placement from intake to invoice, turn its gaps into a short must-have list, trial each finalist on a live role, read the export and renewal terms, and price every seat, add-on and tool you'd keep. Then compare within your model: solo recruiters need one seat that covers sales and admin, boutique desks weigh seat cost and client sharing, and staffing agencies check back office first.

Who this guide is for

Agency owners and lead recruiters choosing a first platform or replacing one, who want a repeatable way to compare vendors before the demos start.

Agency software is often bought in a hurry. A renewal notice lands, a recruiter leaves and takes the spreadsheet logic with them, or a client asks for a shortlist link the current tool can't produce. Demos get booked that week, and the vendor with the smoothest presenter wins.

A better purchase starts on your side of the table. An agency's system serves two customers at once, the candidates you place and the clients who pay the fee, and it has to fit the way your desk really fills a role. It also has to let you leave cleanly, and what it costs is rarely the seat price on the pricing page.

The five checks below take a few hours spread over two weeks. Run them in order, because each one narrows the field for the next.

The five checks at a glance

  1. Map one placement from the first client call to the paid invoice.
  2. Sort must-haves from nice-to-haves, using the gaps the map exposes.
  3. Trial with a live role, not the vendor's sample data.
  4. Read the exit terms: data export, renewal and notice.
  5. Price the whole stack: every seat, add-on, credit and tool you'd keep.

Only one of the five is about features, and it comes second.

1. Map one placement, start to finish

Pick a role you filled recently and write down every step it took, with the tool each step happened in. Be literal. If the job description lived in a shared document and the shortlist went out as an email with three PDFs attached, write that down.

A typical agency placement passes through these stages:

  • Business development: the first conversation with the hiring manager, and the follow-ups that won the role
  • Terms: the fee agreement, sent and signed
  • Intake: the job order, its requirements and the questions that will screen for them
  • Sourcing and advertising: job posts, database searches and outreach to passive candidates
  • Screening: first-round calls or another first step, with notes
  • Submittal: the shortlist sent to the client, and the feedback that comes back
  • Interviews and offer: scheduling, interview notes and the offer
  • Billing: the invoice, tracked until it's paid

Next to each stage, note the tool and the minutes lost copying between tools. For example, a three-recruiter boutique doing this might find that client agreements sit in an e-signature account only the owner can open, that interview notes live in each recruiter's notebook, and that invoices are typed up from memory. Those notes become your shopping list.

2. Turn the gaps into a short must-have list

A must-have is something your desk does every week and would otherwise do by hand, or something a client sees. Everything else is a nice-to-have, however good it looks on a demo. Keep the list to about eight lines so it fits on one page during calls.

Lines that often make an agency's list:

  • Client companies and contacts linked to their roles, so one record shows every role and every candidate sent
  • A candidate record showing every role the person was submitted to, by whom and when
  • Email and calendar sync with the provider you already use, Google or Microsoft
  • Job posting to your careers page and the places your candidates actually look
  • A way to send a client a shortlist and get structured feedback back
  • Interview notes that reach the candidate record without retyping
  • Agreements and invoicing, if you want those subscriptions gone
  • Permissions and reporting by recruiter, once there's more than one of you

Screening needs its own decision. Applications per hire rose 182% from 2021 to 2024, according to Ashby Talent Trends, so a desk that advertises roles may need a first-round step that keeps up. A desk that mostly headhunts may need sourcing and outreach more.

One more rule: anything a vendor calls beta or coming soon can't be a must-have yet. Ask for the status of each line in writing.

3. Trial with a live role

Demo data is built to look good. Your own role, with its messy intake notes and its demanding client, shows where a system bends and where it breaks. Pick one open role, or one you closed last month, and give every finalist the same script:

  1. Build the role from your real intake notes.
  2. Post it, and confirm it appears where candidates will see it.
  3. Add five candidates from three sources: an application, an import and a profile you found yourself.
  4. Screen them the way you would in a normal week, and check where the notes end up.
  5. Send a shortlist to a colleague playing the client, and have them reply with feedback.
  6. Book one interview through the calendar sync and log the outcome.
  7. If agreements and invoicing are on your list, send a test agreement and draft an invoice.

Time each step and note every moment you had to leave the system. Have every recruiter who'll use it daily run steps 3 to 5 themselves, because adoption problems show up in the first hour. For what to ask the vendor alongside the trial, see questions to ask in a recruiting software demo.

4. Read the exit before you sign

The day you choose a system is the cheapest day to ask how you'd leave it. Your candidate database and client history are the agency's main asset, and the contract should treat them that way. Put these to each vendor and keep the answers:

  • What can we export? Candidates, resumes and attachments, client companies and contacts, roles, notes, activity history and placements.
  • In what format, and who runs it? A self-serve CSV export is different from a request support fulfills for a fee.
  • How does our data come in? Who maps the old fields, what it costs and how long it takes.
  • How long is the term, and how does it renew? Monthly or annual, the notice period, and whether renewal is automatic.
  • Can seats go down as well as up? A recruiter leaving mid-term shouldn't leave you paying for an empty seat until renewal.
  • What happens to our data after we cancel? How long it's kept, and how deletion is confirmed.

A vendor that answers quickly and plainly is showing you how the rest of the relationship is likely to go.

5. Price the whole stack

The number on a pricing page is one seat on one plan. What your agency pays is the plan that holds your must-haves, times your seats, plus whatever keeps running beside it. Fill in five lines for each finalist:

  1. Seats at the right tier. Price the plan that holds every must-have, not the entry plan, at both the monthly and the annual rate.
  2. Add-ons and credits. Contact data, sourcing searches and some AI features may be metered or sold separately.
  3. Tools you'd keep. A notetaker, e-signature, invoicing, outreach or scheduling tool the platform doesn't replace stays on the bill.
  4. One-time costs. Setup, migration and training.
  5. Tools you'd cancel. Subtract only the subscriptions the platform really replaces on the tier you priced.

Total it for twelve months, at today's headcount and at the size you expect next year. For how vendors count, per seat, per job or per employee, see how recruiting software is priced.

Which comparison to read next

With the checklist filled in, narrow the field with the comparison that matches how your agency works:

Running Daialog through the same checks

Daialog is one of the platforms you might put through this checklist, so here is how it maps, including where it won't fit.

  • Workflow and must-haves: its ATS and CRM keep Candidate Hub, Intro Hub, roles, departments and clients in one workspace, and it connects to Google and Microsoft email and calendars, LinkedIn, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams. Job postings and InstantIntros are unlimited on every Recruiter and Team plan, and a role can be shared by link or shown on your careers page or careers widget.
  • Screening: with InstantIntro, each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, Daialog's AI screening agent, which assesses it against the role and gives one Match Score with an explanation. Daia doesn't decide who moves forward; your recruiters do.
  • Statuses to note: Talent Search and messaging sequences are in Beta, and text-message steps are coming soon. The AI Notetaker, included in every plan, joins Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls, and Zoom support is coming soon.
  • Where it won't fit: there are no timesheets, payroll or VMS for contract staffing.
  • Pricing: Recruiter is $119 per seat per month, or $99 billed annually. Business Development, invoicing, Signature Hub and Collaboration Hub require Recruiter Plus, at $299 per seat per month or $259 billed annually, which also includes 2,000 People Credits per seat per month for Talent Search and Business Development. Recruiter Custom covers 11 or more seats by quote, and a free trial is available.

Ask us the step 4 questions on export and terms too, and hold every vendor, us included, to the same standard.

Daialog brings the ATS, CRM, InstantIntro screening, the AI Notetaker, e-signature and invoicing together for recruiters and agencies. Start a free trial

Frequently asked questions

How long should an agency trial recruiting software?

Long enough to take one real role from intake to a client shortlist, with every recruiter who will use the system daily taking part. Trial lengths vary by vendor, so start each trial when you have a live role to run through it. Daialog offers a free trial.

Do we need an ATS and a CRM, or one system that does both?

An agency keeps two kinds of record: candidates moving through roles, and the client companies and contacts who pay the fee. Many agency platforms hold both in one system, while an ATS built for employers may have no client records at all. Our guide to ATS vs recruiting CRM covers the difference.

What data should we be able to export if we leave?

Candidates with their resumes and attachments, client companies and contacts, roles, notes, activity history and placements, in a standard format such as CSV. Ask whether export is self-serve or a paid request to support, and get the answer in writing before you sign.

Is AI screening a must-have for a recruiting agency?

It depends on where your recruiters' hours go. If most placements come from headhunting passive candidates, sourcing and outreach matter more. If advertised roles draw more applicants than the desk can screen, a first-round screen belongs on the must-have list. With Daialog's InstantIntro, each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, which assesses it against the role and gives one explained Match Score, and people decide who moves forward.

Does Daialog handle timesheets and payroll for contract placements?

No. Daialog is built for recruiting work, and contract-staffing back office such as timesheets, payroll and VMS isn't part of the product. If your agency places contractors, read our comparison of software for high-volume staffing agencies, which looks at back office alongside recruiting.

Sources

Written by the Daialog Editorial Team. How we research and check Insights.

More from Insights

Keep reading.

More in Buyer guides