If you're the HR generalist at a company of 40 or 140 people, hiring is one job among several. Payroll still runs on schedule, benefits questions keep arriving, and the operations role a manager asked for last week now has a stack of applicants. Nobody on staff recruits full time, so the hiring tool has to fit around the rest of your week.
The first choice is structural. Many HR platforms include a recruiting module, and switching it on is tempting: the vendor, the login and the employee records are already there. A dedicated applicant tracking system usually goes further on hiring, but it's a second system and a second bill, and someone has to make sure a new hire's details reach the HR record.
The second choice is about time. Posting a job takes minutes; the hours go into reading applications, phone screens and scheduling. Ashby Talent Trends found applications per hire rose 182% from 2021 to 2024, so ask each tool what it does for that part of the work.
What matters when hiring is part of an HR job
- Where hiring sits next to your HR records. A module of the HR system you already run, or a separate ATS, and how a hire becomes an employee record.
- Help with the first screen. Application questions, AI review or a screening conversation: whatever cuts the reading and the calls.
- Scheduling. Whether candidates can book interviews without an email thread.
- Manager involvement. How hiring managers see candidates and give feedback without you relaying it.
- The added cost. What you'd pay on top of the HR software you already have.
The five are listed in no particular order; this isn't a ranking.
Daialog (Team plan)
Daialog (Team plan)See how it worksDaialog's plan for in-house talent teams: an ATS with InstantIntro AI screening, hiring-manager shortlists, scheduling, an AI notetaker and e-signature.
- Pricing
- Team from $449 per month ($399 billed annually) for companies of 1–25 employees, with unlimited seats; price scales by employee band. In-House Custom for 1,001+ employees by quote. Pricing page
- Best for
- Small and mid-sized in-house teams that want first-round screening, hiring-manager collaboration and scheduling in one platform with unlimited seats.
- Key features
- ATS with unlimited job postings and InstantIntros
- InstantIntro: each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, assessed against the role
- Collaboration Hub for sharing shortlists with hiring managers
- Calendar and scheduling with Google Calendar and Outlook sync
- Department and budget controls, optional blind screening and Signature Hub
Handing off the first-round screen
Daialog's Team plan is a recruiting platform for in-house teams, and the part a generalist notices first is InstantIntro. Instead of reading every application and booking phone screens yourself, each applicant has a short spoken conversation with Daia, Daialog's AI screening agent. Daia assesses the conversation against the role and gives one Match Score with an explanation. Candidates know they're talking with an AI, and you or the hiring manager decide who moves forward; there's no automatic rejection or knockout. Blind screening is optional and stays off until you turn it on.
The rest of the plan keeps managers involved without you in the middle: the Collaboration Hub shares shortlists with hiring managers, scheduling syncs with Google Calendar and Outlook, department and budget controls are built in, and the AI Notetaker joins Google Meet and Microsoft Teams interviews. Seats are unlimited, and the price is set by company size, from $449 per month, or $399 billed annually, for 1–25 employees. See how it works for in-house teams.
What it leaves to your HR system
- It's a recruiting platform, not an HR system, so payroll and employee records stay where they are today. Its listed integrations are Google and Microsoft email and calendars, LinkedIn, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams, so ask how a new hire's details reach your HR software.
- The price is set by company size band rather than per seat, and the published figure covers 1–25 employees.
- Interview notes come from the AI Notetaker on Google Meet and Microsoft Teams; Zoom support is coming soon.
- AI candidate sourcing (Talent Search) is in Beta.
Daialog's Team plan gives in-house teams an ATS with InstantIntro screening, hiring-manager shortlists and scheduling, with unlimited seats. Start a free trial
BambooHR
BambooHROfficial siteHR software covering people data, payroll, benefits and hiring, with a built-in applicant tracking system that runs from job posting to onboarding.
- Pricing
- Per employee/month (USD): Core $10, Pro $17, Elite $25 on plan cards (FAQ: $10.25/$17.50/$25). 25 or fewer employees: flat $250/$425/$650 a month. Month-to-month or longer terms. Pricing page
- Best for
- Small and growing businesses that want applicant tracking, offers and onboarding inside their HR system rather than a separate recruiting tool.
- Key features
- Job posting to boards such as Indeed, ZipRecruiter and LinkedIn, with posts and candidates managed in one place.
- Collaborative candidate review with custom permissions, automatic alerts and in-system messaging.
- Candidates pick from preset interview times, with automated confirmations.
- Offer letter templates that auto-populate candidate details, with e-signatures.
- Candidate Sources and Candidate Funnel reports.
If BambooHR already holds your employee records
BambooHR's applicant tracking comes inside its HR plans, so a company already on BambooHR has no new vendor to add. It runs from job posting to onboarding, and for a generalist the valuable part is the end: when someone is hired, their data moves to the employee record automatically, and new-hire packets and onboarding checklists pick up from there, so the basics don't need typing in twice.
Along the way, colleagues review candidates under custom permissions with alerts and in-system messaging, candidates choose from preset interview times with automated confirmations, and offer letters fill in candidate details and collect e-signatures. Pricing is per employee per month, Core $10, Pro $17 and Elite $25 on the plan cards (the FAQ lists $10.25, $17.50 and $25), with flat rates of $250, $425 or $650 a month for 25 or fewer employees. Terms run month-to-month or longer, and there's a 7-day free trial.
Where the module's limits show
- Job openings are capped by plan: 5 on Core, 25 on Pro and 50 on Elite. Five open roles is a real ceiling during a hiring push.
- Applicant tracking isn't sold as a standalone product on the pricing page; you buy it as part of an HR plan.
- If you outgrow it, BambooHR's marketplace has an Applicant Tracking Systems category for connecting a third-party ATS, so changing recruiting tools doesn't mean leaving BambooHR for HR.
Rippling
RipplingOfficial siteRippling Recruiting is an AI-native ATS inside Rippling's workforce platform, connecting hiring with Rippling's HRIS, onboarding and payroll.
- Pricing
- Recruiting price not published (quote). Rippling says plans start at $8 per employee per month plus a monthly base fee, varying by products chosen. Pricing page
- Best for
- Growing companies that use or adopt Rippling's HRIS and want recruiting tied to headcount approvals, onboarding and payroll.
- Key features
- Posts jobs to thousands of boards, with native LinkedIn and Indeed integrations.
- Candidates book interviews based on panelists' real-time calendar availability.
- Knockout questions automatically filter out candidates who hit custom dealbreakers.
- Candidate texting from Rippling, plus bulk moving, emailing or rejecting of candidates.
- Employee referral hub with bonuses paid out automatically through Rippling Payroll.
When hiring should follow headcount approvals
Rippling Recruiting is an ATS inside Rippling's workforce platform, and its case for an HR generalist is the chain from budget to payroll: approved headcount opens a requisition, a signed offer triggers onboarding in the same system, and referral bonuses pay out through Rippling Payroll. If you already run Rippling's HRIS, several manual handoffs disappear.
It also takes on screening work. Application Review screens candidates against custom criteria to surface the applications that fit the job, candidates book interviews from panelists' real-time calendar availability, and Interview Assistant records, transcribes and summarizes interviews.
What you're committing to
- Recruiting requires Rippling's base HRIS platform and is priced as an add-on to it, so it makes sense for Rippling customers or companies adopting its HRIS anyway.
- Recruiting prices aren't published; they're quoted per employee per month by company size, hiring needs and features. Rippling says its plans start at $8 per employee per month plus a monthly base fee, varying by the products chosen.
- Knockout questions filter out candidates automatically when they hit a dealbreaker you set. Keep them narrow if you want a person to see borderline applicants.
Gusto
Payroll, benefits and HR platform for small businesses; its Plus and Premium plans add job postings, applicant tracking, offer letters and onboarding.
- Pricing
- Simple $49/mo + $7/mo per person; Plus $99/mo + $12/mo per person; Premium $179/mo + $22/mo per person. Applicant tracking and job postings on Plus and Premium only. No contracts. Pricing page
- Best for
- Small businesses running payroll on Gusto that want simple job posting, applicant tracking and onboarding without a separate recruiting tool.
- Key features
- Company job board with job posts, free LinkedIn posting and free syndication to 100+ boards via Jobcase (vendor figure)
- Hiring teams review and score applicants, move them through stages and review in bulk.
- Custom or preset application questions, with preferred answers to screen applicants.
- Offer letter templates with e-signatures on all plans; custom offer letter templates on Plus and Premium.
- Send an offer letter and import new hires directly into Gusto onboarding and payroll.
For a company that already runs payroll on Gusto
Gusto is payroll, benefits and HR software for small businesses, and its Plus and Premium plans add job postings, applicant tracking, offer letters and onboarding. You post to a company job board, with free LinkedIn posting and free syndication via Jobcase to what Gusto says are 100+ boards, your hiring team scores applicants and moves them through stages, and once the offer letter goes out, new hires import directly into Gusto onboarding and payroll.
For a first filter, you can set preferred answers to application questions, and Gusto can draft a job description from the title (it advises checking AI drafts for mistakes). Plus is $99/mo + $12/mo per person and Premium $179/mo + $22/mo per person, with no contracts; the Simple plan doesn't include applicant tracking.
The manual work that remains
- Gusto Recruiting has no interview scheduling or applicant email templates and sends no automated emails to applicants, so you'll arrange interviews and write to candidates yourself.
- Sponsored job promotion runs through Jobcase and is paid separately, starting at $25.
- Background checks are a paid add-on on every plan.
- If the manual steps start costing you too much time, Gusto syncs with third-party applicant tracking systems to view candidates and import new hires into payroll.
Breezy HR
Hiring software and applicant tracking system covering job advertising, screening, interviews and offers, with optional AI, onboarding and performance tools.
- Pricing
- Startup $157, Growth $273, Business $439 per month billed annually ($189, $329, $529 billed monthly); Custom Pro by quote. Flat per-plan price with unlimited users and positions. Pricing page
- Positioned for growing and midsize employers; agencies work through a recruiter portal for submitting candidates (Growth plan and up).
- Best for
- Growing and midsize employers wanting flat plan pricing with unlimited users and positions, and optional credit-based AI screening.
- Key features
- Posts jobs to 50+ job boards and includes a customizable, branded career site (vendor figure)
- Candidate questionnaires, stage-based automations and bulk actions for screening applicants.
- Interview self-scheduling with built-in video meetings or Zoom, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams.
- One-way candidate video screening on all plans.
- Scorecards, interview guides, reference checks, employee referrals and e-signatures from the Growth plan.
A dedicated ATS that doesn't charge by the person
Breezy HR is a standalone applicant tracking system for growing and midsize employers, with flat plan prices: Startup $157, Growth $273 and Business $439 per month billed annually, or $189, $329 and $529 billed monthly. Every plan has unlimited users and unlimited positions, so you can bring in every hiring manager without counting seats.
Several features aim at the screening load: candidate questionnaires, stage-based automations and bulk actions, one-way video screening on all plans, and interview self-scheduling. Its AI features include Applicant Insights, which scores applicants 0–10 against the job and up to five criteria and explains each score, and Resume Audit, which flags resumes that look auto-generated, copied or keyword-stuffed.
Tiers that matter if you also run HR
- HRIS integrations start on the Business plan, as do offer management, approvals and assessment integrations. If hires should flow into BambooHR, ADP or Gusto, price Business, not Startup.
- Breezy Intelligence AI is a credit-based add-on, from $30 per 100,000 credits, and Interview Analysis is a separate subscription.
- API access, advanced reporting and data export or import are options on the quote-based Custom Pro plan.
Built-in module or separate tool: five situations
- You're on BambooHR and rarely have more than a few roles open. The module on your plan already covers posting, review, interview booking, offers and onboarding. Revisit when you reach your plan's openings cap, which is 5 on Core.
- You run payroll on Gusto Plus or Premium and hire occasionally. Gusto handles posting and tracking; scheduling and candidate emails are yours. If that load grows, Breezy HR lists Gusto among its HRIS integrations from the Business plan.
- You're on Rippling, or about to adopt it. Recruiting ties requisitions to approved headcount and offers to onboarding, so ask for a quote on the add-on before looking elsewhere.
- Applications arrive faster than you can read them. That's a screening problem more than a tracking one. Daialog's Team plan gives applicants a spoken first-round conversation with Daia. If you'd rather keep the ATS you have, InstantIntro is also sold as a standalone plan next to an existing ATS; it connects to BambooHR and Breezy through a third-party connector, and only Workable has a direct connection.
- Several managers need access and you don't want per-person pricing. Breezy HR has unlimited users on every plan, and Daialog's Team plan has unlimited seats priced by company size.
Where the hiring hours go, step by step
- Reading applications. Written applications are harder to take at face value: in a 2024 CV Genius survey of hiring managers in the UK and Ireland, 74% said they can tell when AI wrote an application. Gusto filters on preferred answers to your questions, Rippling's Application Review and Breezy HR's Applicant Insights screen against criteria you set, Breezy's Resume Audit flags resumes that look auto-generated, and Daialog gives you a spoken conversation with each applicant to review.
- First-round calls. Phone screens take calendar time for every applicant you advance. InstantIntro is built as that first-round screen, and Breezy HR's one-way video screening, on all plans, is another way to hear from candidates before booking a call.
- Scheduling. BambooHR candidates pick from preset interview times, Rippling books from panelists' real-time availability, Breezy HR has self-scheduling, and Daialog's scheduling syncs with Google Calendar and Outlook. Gusto Recruiting doesn't include interview scheduling.
- Notes and manager feedback. Rippling's Interview Assistant transcribes and summarizes interviews, and its Candidate Feedback Summaries condense scorecards for hiring managers. In Daialog, the AI Notetaker covers Google Meet and Microsoft Teams interviews, and shortlists reach managers through the Collaboration Hub. Breezy HR adds scorecards and interview guides from the Growth plan.
- Offer and handoff to HR. This is where HR modules earn their place: BambooHR transfers hire data to employee records, Gusto imports new hires into onboarding and payroll, and Rippling starts onboarding when an offer is signed. With a separate ATS, check the connection before you buy.
If price decides it, our guide to affordable applicant tracking systems works through first-year costs plan by plan. Recruiting software for small businesses looks at the wider choice, and recruiting software for startups covers companies hiring fast from a small base.










